Tuesday, December 9, 2014

Part II: The Misguided Racial Politics of Rape Culture

Before I begin, I will posit that if "rape culture" was real, this figure wouldn't exist:
Self-Explanatory
Nor would this statement from the Rape, Abuse, & Incest National Network (RAINN) in a letter to the White House: 
"In the last few years, there has been an unfortunate trend towards blaming “rape culture” for the extensive problem of sexual violence on campuses. While it is helpful to point out the systemic barriers to addressing the problem, it is important to not lose sight of a simple fact: Rape is caused not by cultural factors but by the conscious decisions, of a small percentage of the community, to commit a violent crime"
You would think that the nation's largest and most respected survivor's advocacy group debunking rape culture would mean something. Apparently not, because you can't go two days without reading about the ubiquitous "one in five" statistic, which has been repeatedly shown as highly misleading.

I encourage everyone to read the original study that produced that figure. I won't go so far as to say (as many conservative pundits have) that the study was "highly flawed", but I will say as someone who has designed and conducted similar studies (and knows a good bit about research methods) that the conclusions many have drawn from its results are incredibly unfounded. The study was a self-response, web-based online survey. I've run a couple of these, and can say that half the time, people either won't finish or they will skip questions. Most researchers who care about getting good data will only resort to this design as a last resort. Additionally, if you look during the portion of the paper that discusses the survey itself, you can see that all the questions are pretty ambiguously worded; researchers thought this was the best route to take rather than specifically ask participants if they had been raped or sexually assaulted. While in theory this sounds like it would strengthen construct validity because it gives accounts of situations rather than relying on the participants' own personal definition of "rape" and "sexual assault", items were coded as such in the analysis. For example, "sex while intoxicated" was considered rape under the justification that one cannot give consent while intoxicated. True, but the majority of responses interpreted as "rape" came from this response or a couple others like it. In other words, while researchers designated participants' responses to be rape, many of the participants (both men and women) probably wouldn't consider themselves rape victims. Have you ever had sex while drunk? According to the interpretation of this study, you were raped. Have you ever had sex with a drunk person? Guess what; you're a rapist.
I won't even get into the problematic demographics of the study, which like most studies of this kind using college students as participants, was over 80% white.

Now here are some more figures from RAINN. Black women have a slightly higher rape/attempted rape prevalence rate (18.8%) than white women (17.7%), mixed-race women are higher than both (24.4%), but Native American women have the highest at 34.1%. Rape is a legitimate epidemic on reservations, yet I never hear ANYONE talk about it.

Rape on reservations is an empirically confirmed problem, but why isn't it a focus for activism? Short answer: the victims and perpetrators aren't white, so it doesn't fit in with the convenient assumption of rape as the weapon of white patriarchal hegemony. There is this dimension of (mostly) white women who seem to think that the "oppressed" status of their gender due to rape culture's ubiquity negates any privilege afforded to them by their race. The fact that anyone even tries to make this assertion is fucking laughable considering a century of demographic/sociological data that clearly establishes race as a much stronger variable in predicting socioeconomic status than gender. It is even more absurd considering that the majority who make this claim are upper-middle class college-educated white people. 

Look no further than the viral "10 Hours of Walking in NYC as a Woman" video; white privilege is being able to afford to get offended when black and Hispanic men catcall you when you walk through their neighborhood. Furthermore, it isn't like these guys are just black and Hispanic men on their lunch break, it's dudes loitering. Forget calling attention to how easily the racial disparities in unemployment can be seen just by walking through non-white neighborhoods, this is men behaving like pigs on camera. Street harassment isn't okay, and maybe you could go so far as to say that for these individuals, similar patterns of behavior might be why they can't hold down a job. Women shouldn't have to be fearful to walk around in public. But guys that catcall women are only slightly less pathetic than guys who drunkenly creep on/grope women at the bar. Call people out who behave as such, and tell them that it isn't okay... or just punch them in the face. I'm not a huge fan of cultural relativism, but in this case, ask yourself whether or not anyone who is inherently sexist will really change their behavior just because a white woman got offended? Fuck no. Just take a minute to consider how much it sucks to live amongst people who treat women as such on a daily basis. These women are in the most unfortunate position possible because they literally can't afford to get offended for their own safety and livelihood. That is true oppression. 

How about a followup video called "10 Minutes of Walking in Johannesburg/New Delhi/Islamabad/Kinshasha as a Woman"? Probably will never happen because rape culture actually exists as the status quo in these places. It isn't just some nebulous concept supported by bad science thrown around by women's studies majors and feminist bloggers, it is a sad and horrific reality for many women of color around the world. 

I'll probably come back to this later at some point, but these are just a few of the points I wanted to make in my previous piece today that felt much better addressed on their own. A note on the statistics: every study that has ever been done on how vastly underreported rape is compared to other violent crimes has confirmed that only a small fraction of rapes that occur are ever reported to police. The figures above are only a reflection of reported rapes, not the prevalence of how many are actually committed. Judging from the points I've made above and in other pieces, I think one can reasonably infer that non-white women are significantly less likely to report being raped, whether it be due to cultural stigma, fear, distrust of authorities, or all of the above. I find this unacceptable. I find it equally unacceptable that many who promote rape culture conveniently whitewash the fuck out of it, conveniently ignore situations that don't support their own understanding, then attack anyone who opposes their views as a rape-apologist or misogynist. I hope that I have sufficiently demonstrated that I am neither. I just don't like misguided agendas.


EDIT: 12/12/14 12:08PM-

Yesterday (or maybe the day before), the Department of Justice released the results of a study comparing the rates of rape and sexual assault victimization of college-age females from 1995-2013. Guess what? Women ages 18-24 who are not enrolled at a college or university are 1.2 times as likely to be raped or sexually assaulted compared to their student peers. Again, we can probably infer that the "student" sample was predominantly white and the non-student sample was predominantly non-white. However, contrary to my original hypothesis, students were more likely to NOT report being raped/sexually assaulted than non-students. This is probably the most troubling finding of all, and (I believe) accurately reflects the way many colleges and universities handle sexual assaults- keep it internal, don't get the police involved. Anyway, read the study for yourself. Either way, I think we can put the nail in the coffin for the "one in five" figure.

Why White People Should Shut the Fuck Up and Listen

Or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying About Being White

I thought about making a post consisting entirely of "Condescending Wonka" memes, but half the time there was too much text to fit. If I had to make just one, it would be:

Top Caption: Oh, so you're an upper-middle class white person who went to college and now fights for social justice?
Bottom Caption: Please, tell me more about white privilege and racism in society.

In the words of Matt Stone (co-creator of South Park), "I hate conservatives, but I really fucking hate liberals". 

A short explanation of that quote is that for a sizable portion of conservatives, religion trumps all. Naturally, they expect and welcome any criticism since godless liberals are in a conspiracy with Satan to destroy Christianity and America.

Yeah.... right. But practically speaking, there are only so many jokes you can make about that, and the most of them are already overdone.

Liberals, however, with almighty secular "science" and "reason" on their side, tend to take an intellectually enlightened stance on social issues; they believe they are above reproach. In Parker and Stone's view, this is exactly why liberals need to be put in place- no one is immune to criticism. That also is kindof the theme of this blog (if you haven't figured it out already).

I should clarify here that I do in fact identify as a liberal. I am a registered Democrat, and (for the most part) have voted as such in every election cycle since I turned 18. 

So naturally, I guess I should go attend a "die-in", change my profile picture to #BlackLivesMatter on Facebook, and lecture about white privilege and how fucked up it is to anyone I come in contact with.

This is blatant "whitesplaining", a term that I hope hasn't already been coined by someone else.

whitesplain (wAHYT-spleyn)
verb
1. Portmanteau of "white" and "explain"; an unintentionally condescending (though often well-intentioned) attempt to describe issues such as racial/gender/socioeconomic inequality from a privileged perspective.
2. Anything said on social media about current events coming from a "white liberal" between the ages of 18-30.
noun, whitesplanation

Here's a little bit of history for you. A very popular literary genre in 19th century America was the "slave narrative". Two of most highly regarded works in this genre are the eponymous Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave, and Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl by Harriet Jacobs. 

Side note: If you haven't read either of these, I highly recommend them. Both stories portray a graphic depiction of slavery's moral and physical brutality much better than any movie ever could. 

Usually, slave narratives were serialized by Abolitionist publications and were as such written to an audience of (mostly) wealthy white New Englanders who composed the core of the Abolitionist movement. Considering the place which slavery held in public discourse prior to the Civil War, it isn't difficult to see how these stories became widely read and won many formerly apathetic individuals over to the Abolitionist cause. 

One of the trademarks of the genre was that the accounts were often published with a foreword/prologue by a prominent (white) Abolitionist, usually praising the author's integrity and providing validation to the story (I've linked Douglass's piece above, check out the foreword). So maybe you can see where I'm going with this. Former slaves became figurepieces of the Abolitionist movement. After the Civil War, a lot of Abolitionists felt that it was their duty to help "the feeble Negro" fully exercise his newfound freedom. So they aren't slaves anymore... but they aren't fully people yet either since they couldn't be expected to get far without the white man's help and validation. So yes, while well-intentioned, white people trying to "guide" black people to equality is patronizing, ignorant, and an implicit societal message that black people are "less-than". I guess I should take this opportunity to point out that the most widely-read book of the nineteenth century is often lumped into the slave narrative genre even though it is fiction written by a white woman: Uncle Tom's Cabin by Harriet Beecher Stowe. The book had a much larger impact on society than any real slave narrative, and although it was indeed written with the most noble objectives, it is responsible for many negative stereotypes of blacks that still exist in our culture over 160 years later.

Let's get back to the present. People are outraged over the happenings in Ferguson, New York, and everywhere else where black people are disproportionately targeted by law enforcement (which is most places). People should be outraged. But this is turning into a fucking cause célèbre for a bunch of white people to tell everyone else how radically inclusive and egalitarian they are and how much they care about how fucked our society is; all of this at the expense of drowning out the voices of those who exist at a societal disadvantage.

Yes, black lives matter. But black lives are lost every day at a rate much higher than any other demographic group. In this case, the outrage was spurred mostly by the (white) media circus surrounding Ferguson. You know what message this sends? That the grievances of blacks aren't "legitimate" or "real" until white people get involved to provide the figurative supporting foreword to their frustrations.

It doesn't matter how much you care about racial inequality, how many classes about it you took in college, or how many student activist groups you were a member of, if you are white, you don't know shit about discrimination or injustice, and you need to quit pretending that you do. This isn't your fight. It is trite and patronizing for you to think that you can actually contribute anything new or meaningful to a very real struggle that you can't even begin to understand. Additionally, it devalues the experiences of black people who have dealt with adversity since birth; adversity that they didn't ask for or deserve, but became an inherent aspect of their existence only because of the color of their skin. No amount of empathy will ever amount to you "understanding" the non-white experience in America.

So as a white male, I am pleading with my white peers to shut the fuck up and listen. Not understanding is okay. You can still be supportive of the black community while simultaneously acknowledging your own whiteness (and thus, undeserved privilege) by not joining into the fury, but taking it all in and trying to learn how best you can be of service to people who are disadvantaged. Don't assume you know how to help best, or you know what the "right" thing to do is. If you really care that much, show some fucking humility and ask.





Thursday, December 4, 2014

White privilege is not getting arrested

Bill Maher probably made the best point of anyone I've heard comment on the deaths of Eric Garner and Michael Brown as the direct result of police using unnecessary force.
"I'd just like to know what a cop WOULD have to do to get indicted - and what good are cop cameras since Eric Garner IS on tape?"
I do remember a case that was in the news here in Charlotte a few years ago of a police officer killing an unarmed black man. Read about it here, because this case closely mirrors recent events; the main difference being that there wasn't an extraordinary effort by prosecutors and police to try and shield one of their own from any consequences.

Other Charlotte police officers (here, and here) have been indicted for sex crimes.

So it apparently seems that Charlotte Mecklenburg Police are fairly accountable. Personally, I've only had excellent interactions with CMPD. "Excellent interactions" is a euphemism for getting caught with a bunch of drugs and walking away from it with no consequences because I'm white.

So way back in November of 2008, I was back in Charlotte for the weekend. My band was playing a show at Lunchbox Records that night (a Friday I believe), and per usual, this involved brown-bagging 40s and FourLoko before, during, and after we played because Plaza-Midwood used to be sketchy like that. After the show, the plan was to go to some party up near University, which at that time was not the safest place in town. I drove up there and parked near the entrance to the neighborhood to wait for some friends who I was going to follow to the house (this was before everyone had iPhones with GPS). Before I know it, I see blue lights behind me. And ironically enough, I was listening to NWA's "Fuck Tha Police" very loudly.

Yes, this really did happen.

So instead of taking the time to hide everything, I was too busy trying to switch my iPod to Hank Williams... since I figured cops like Hank? Well as the cops walked up, I decided I would just get out of the car to talk to them and maybe they wouldn't search my car.

Turns out the two cops were black. Maybe Hank wasn't the best choice. The one I talked to looked like Terry Crews with a moustache that not so subtly screamed "I made the 1970s my bitch". So basically imagine a 6'4, jacked-as-fuck Steve Harvey.

I don't know why, but I actually told the cop the truth... well, most of the truth. Admitted that I'd been drinking, that I had open containers in the car, and that there "may be some other stuff". But no guns! I promised him he wouldn't find any sort of weapon in the car as he told me that he had probable cause to search the car.

I knew what was in my car. I was about to go to jail for a long time. I also knew that making this dude's life difficult was only going to make anything else that followed much worse for me.

So in all, I had Schedules I, II, and III covered, in addition to a few open containers.

I was fucked. I didn't try to make any excuses at this point because I knew there was no way out.

But instead of cuffing me, this cop started asking me what I was doing with my life. I told him I was a freshman at UNC. I will never forget what he told me next: "Son, you've got everything in the world going for you right now, why are you killing yourself?"
I don't even know how I answered that. I just know that next, he was asking me if him taking me in would get me kicked out of school. I said something to the extent of "well I think I've got two felonies as it stands now, so yeah, I think I would get expelled". Then he asked me what I was doing in that part of town, so I told him.

He said "alright, wait for your friends, go to that party, and I better not see you driving anywhere else tonight. We only stopped because there have been a number of car jackings and assaults in this area recently, and we wanted to make sure everything was alright. A nice car in this part of town, you'd be an easy target." And then he left.

If I wasn't suffering from opiate-induced constipation, I definitely would have shit my pants at some point during this encounter. But I had clean underwear, and off I went.

I've thought about this a lot over the past 6 years. I don't know why that cop let me go. Me being white certainly had something to do with it- despite having drugs on me, I wasn't seen as a threat. Also, it probably wasn't worth the paper work. I also think that the cops' race had something to do with it as well.

Most police officers are white, and come from working-class white backgrounds (i.e., probably hold more racist views than other segments of white society). A lot of career cops only have a high school diploma, maybe a 2-year degree. These aren't the smartest guys in the world. That's why they became cops. I don't know this as a fact, but I would be willing to guess that on average, black cops are much more educated than white cops. A combination of education and experience on both sides of the legal system (experience as a young black male and experience as a law enforcement officer) give black cops a much more complete perspective to apply to their work. Let me put it this way; white cops are more likely to be white cops because they come from a long line of family who have worked in law enforcement for generations, and thus it is a career path that is virtually handed to them. In the back of their minds, they are thinking "well, if ______ doesn't pan out, I can just become a cop like my old man". Black cops? There is a lot of (COMPLETELY JUSTIFIED) distrust in the black community against police. As a black man in 21st century America, you don't just wake up one day and say "I guess I'll just be a cop". You work hard for that shit your entire life. You don't get that gun and badge because you think you're entitled to it; you get it because you earned it and you intend to use it justly to make the world a better place. You work your ass off because you know that once you reach that goal, no matter what you do, all these white people around you who just got into law enforcement for shits and giggles will just assume you got there because of affirmative action.

That being said, if I were black, I would have been arrested, regardless of the officers' respective races. Because unfortunately, being a black male in 2014 is still probable cause.

I wonder how things would be different if most cops were black?

Wednesday, December 3, 2014

Now on Eric Garner

As described in one of my previous posts, from a legal standpoint, I could understand why Darren Wilson wasn't indicted for his killing of Michael Brown.

The fact that Daniel Pantaleo isn't being charged with manslaughter at the very least is a fucking insult to any notion of police accountability for misconduct.

Differences between this case and Ferguson make it even more outrageous.

1. Eric Garner didn't resist arrest.
2. Police officers have guns and are allowed to use them under certain circumstances. Police are NEVER allowed to detain suspects using a chokehold.
3. The coroner who examined Garner's body ruled his death a homicide
4. Eric Garner was selling bootleg cigarettes in a city that charges $14 a pack. Correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe tobacco bootlegging is under the jurisdiction of the ATF, ie the FEDERAL GOVERNMENT. Not the NYPD. If convicted, I'm fairly certain that not only is it a felony, but you have to repay whatever amount of money you are convicted of defrauding from the State via tax dollars.
5. IT WAS ON FUCKING VIDEO. THE WHOLE THING. GO WATCH IT.

We aren't ever going to know what REALLY happened in Ferguson. But we know what happened in Staten Island. And there is no justice.

If Eric Garner were white, there still wouldn't have been an indictment because Eric Garner wouldn't have been killed because police wouldn't have deemed the use of a chokehold "necessary force" against a white man.

#ACAB

Why UVA Gang Rape is Becoming Duke Lacrosse Part Two

WHY UVA GANG RAPE IS ANOTHER DUKE LACROSSE CASE

Except this time around, there are no facts anywhere to be found


For the sake of length, I won't even go into all the ways that the 2006 Duke Lacrosse rape scandal was a colossal fuck up; William D. Cohan wrote a 600+ page book on the subject, brilliantly reviewed and summarized here by Laura Miller in a piece for Salon. If you have no idea what I'm talking about, go read about it. Go read about it anyway just to refresh your memory. If you're more into skimming Wikipedia, that page is found here.

...So now that we're all on the same page here, let's get started. Crystal Mangum's accusations ended up being false. The three men she identified were chosen at random from a suspect lineup pool composed ENTIRELY of members of the Duke Lacrosse team (everybody wins!) as District Attorney Mike Nifong and the Durham Police Department had apparently never watched an episode of Law & Order: SVU. But despite the dubious credibility of the accuser (who is now in prison for murder), the shady tactics of law enforcement and Nifong (who has since been disbarred), and the knee-jerk reaction of Duke University and Duke faculty, certain facts about the case remain:

1. On March 13, 2006, two strippers were hired to perform at the off-campus residence of members of the Duke Lacrosse team.
2. The players, who had requested white strippers, were not pleased when two non-white strippers arrived at the party (one of whom was accuser Crystal Mangum).
3. A vulgar exchange of words took place between the strippers and their audience; this abruptly stopped the performance, and the two strippers left.
4. The exchange of words reached a pinnacle as the women drove away.

Somehow, some way, this culminated in Mangum reporting to authorities that she had been gang raped by three of the men present.

*cue firestorm*

The main difference here is that it was (rightfully, although ineptly) investigated by police, not the university (more on that later). But here's the thing; facts are present in this incident. As unsavory as they may be, we have a pretty clear picture of what happened. Are the Duke lacrosse players guilty of being huge douchebags? Absolutely; I think anyone who has ever met a Duke lacrosse player could attest to that (joking... kindof).

If you look at it from an unbiased perspective, it becomes increasingly more ridiculous to suggest that entitled young white men who have had their futures already handed to them would be willing to risk any of that by raping a mentally unstable black stripper. Especially in Durham, NC. Being a consummate example of douchebaggery does not make you a rapist.

The story of the UVA gang rape as reported in Rolling Stone is similar for many reasons. Firstly, it provides a narrative that panders to the readers assumptions about college, fraternities, and the behavior of the men who join these groups; they are over-privileged white kids who feel entitled to whatever they want... especially innocent, working-class freshman women. Richard Bradley, who as editor of George was duped by Stephen Glass, said it much better than I can:
"Stephen wrote what he knew I was inclined to believe. And because I was inclined to believe it, I abandoned my critical judgment. I lowered my guard.The lesson I learned: One must be most critical, in the best sense of that word, about what one is already inclined to believe. So when, say, the Duke lacrosse scandal erupted, I applied that lesson. The story was so sensational! Believing it required indulging one’s biases: A southern school…rich white preppy boys…a privileged sports team…lower class African-American women…rape. It read like a Tom Wolfe novel.
And of course it never happened."
When I first read Sabrina Rubin Erdley's piece, I felt extremely uncomfortable. Not because of the subject matter, but it was a strange feeling I couldn't place. Part deja vu, part feeling like I was being fed a story that just seemed "too good to be true". Again, in Richard Bradley's words:

"Let me be very clear: I don’t doubt that it’s possible that this happened. People can do terrible things, things that one doesn’t want to believe happen. And I certainly don’t want to think that this could have happened. 
But more than that: I don’t believe that it happened—certainly not in the way that it is recounted. 
Remember: One must be most critical about stories that play into existing biases. And this story nourishes a lot of them: biases against fraternities, against men, against the South; biases about the naïveté of young women, especially Southern women; pre-existing beliefs about the prevalence—indeed, the existence—of rape culture; extant suspicions about the hostility of university bureaucracies to sexual assault complaints that can produce unflattering publicity."
To roughly paraphrase a buddy of mine during a recent conversation we had on this topic, he put into words what I could not articulate; he noted that in trying to present a perfect story that hits all the right nerves to serve as the backdrop for some very real and very disturbing actions by UVA's administration in handling sexual assaults, the end product was a narrative that is "100% outside the realm of possibility". In my own words, my first reaction was "that doesn't fucking happen".

Before I move on to this next part, I do want to put out this disclaimer: Rubin Erdley's reporting on UVA's handling of sexual assaults was excellent. I have no doubt that universities do a shitty job of handling sexual assault. I have no doubt that administrators would much rather silence survivors by investigating reported assaults internally rather than through the proper channels of the criminal justice system.

But the account of gang rape is 95% complete and utter bullshit, at least from the perspective from which it was presented.

After this next clarification, I will tell you why (and rather than read this part, a lot of you will just put a "rape apologist/misogynist" stamp on this and move on).

Firstly, although I did not go to UVA, I was in a fraternity at UNC. If you had to pick any college that is most similar to the campus culture and Greek system at UVA, it would be UNC. For the most part, I would say that the general public's conception of the "frat boy" stereotype is mostly accurate for fraternities and their members at most colleges and universities in the south (South Carolina, Georgia, Alabama, other SEC schools). UNC and UVA are extremely different, however. It's probably the result of a combination of different factors, including but not limited to:

  • Virginia and North Carolina didn't get completely fucked by Reconstruction. Generations of well-off Southerners in these two states remained well-off and could afford to send their kids to college. They are two of the more socially progressive states (relatively speaking) south of the Mason-Dixon Line. In fact, I would say most "Southerners" don't even consider Virginia to be a part of the South.
  • Selectivity; UNC and UVA are widely considered "public Ivies" for both the quality of the education, the acceptance rate for applicants, the subjective "prestige" of the institution itself, and a very wealthy alumni base. As noted in the RS piece, the "study hard, play hard" mentality is central. UVA and UNC are party schools that are actually schools.
  • Greek organizations at UNC and UVA exercise a disproportionate degree of influence on student life considering their numbers only amount to somewhere between 15-20% of the student population at both institutions. This leads to a certain degree of distrust and animosity between fraternities and non-affiliated students.
  • Both institutions have long-standing "honor codes" as a central standard of student conduct; violations of the honor code are heard by a student-run forum/committee/whatever at both institutions. This is a central problem to the way in which both UNC and UVA handle sexual assaults.


You could say I am very familiar with what goes on at UNC because I was there for six years. I should also note that the last four years I was there, I was sober, and was still an active member of the fraternity I pledged in fall 2008. So it would be entirely accurate to say that I've "seen a lot of shit". And this is why the RS story bothered me; it was portraying an image of fraternities that would seem incredibly accurate to anyone who hasn't been in a fraternity at either of these institutions.

AND HERE IS WHY NONE OF IT HAPPENED (at least in the way it was told)...

1. First-year students can only (officially) rush/pledge in the spring semester (via IFC 2012-2013 manual). Fall rush/pledging is only available for transfers/second-year students. Fraternities put much more focus on recruiting freshmen as opposed to upperclassmen simply because they will be around (and paying dues) for an additional year. Looking at the schedule, it can be easily seen that fall rush is a formality, and the focus is on spring. It was the other way around at UNC- everyone did fall rush, but spring rush was entirely optional until a few years ago. I imagine it's similar at UVA (other way around of course).
This puts a lot of doubt on the assertion that the gang rape was some sort of pledge initiation ritual, suggested as such in this paragraph of the RS piece:
"As the last man sank onto her, Jackie was startled to recognize him: He attended her tiny anthropology discussion group. He looked like he was going to cry or puke as he told the crowd he couldn't get it up. "Pussy!" the other men jeered. "What, she's not hot enough for you?" Then they egged him on: "Don't you want to be a brother?" "We all had to do it, so you do, too."
"
Bid day in 2012 was on September 22, the attack occurred September 28. For a minute, let's assume that Phi Kappa Psi does require their pledges to take part in a gang rape in order to be initiated. Why the fuck are they doing it in the FIRST WEEK of pledging; furthermore, the first week of pledging for SOPHOMORES? That isn't how this works. All I will say about my own experience with the pledging process is that it is the best time of my life that I never want to have again. The entire purpose of pledging (whether or not hazing is present) is to take your pledge class of X number individuals and turn it into a single unit. The first week of pledging isn't when you decide to arbitrarily inflict the most deranged, fucked up hazing ritual of your brotherhood onto some unsuspecting kids that still have the leftover idea from rush that you're their best friend. You know what would happen? They would fucking quit. I think anyone in their right mind would quit faced with that incredibly fucked up scenario. Additionally, it being an initiation ritual and all, means every active brother in Phi Kappa Psi has taken part. Do you even realize how fucking retarded that suggestion is? In the age of Facebook, Twitter, Snapchat, YikYak, etc, PEOPLE FIND OUT ABOUT SHIT (KD blumpkin girl- need I say more?). This would have come to light A LOT sooner. Phi Kappa Psi would not have their "upper tier" reputation (which according to a friend who went to UVA, saying PKP is "upper tier" is like calling Applebee's "gourmet New American-fusion cuisine"), and soon enough that reputation would lead to them not having any kids wanting to pledge there at all. Furthermore, any sort of activity for pledges that takes place isn't for the purpose of uniting them with older brothers, it's for uniting them amongst themselves. The pledge class wasn't only those 6 dudes. An "upper tier" fraternity is looking at at least 25 kids. So do they take shifts or what? That would defeat the fucking purpose, a purpose which has already been thrown out the window due to the fact that FUCKING RAPE is the activity. So this already is flimsy because it is strongly suggested that the individual in one of Jackie's classes was also a first-year. I'm not dumb, and I know PKP is most likely rushing freshmen before "formal recruitment". But having pledges off the books? It's stupid and there is no reason to do it. The risk greatly outweighs the potential benefit of having a few individuals pay dues for an extra semester.
2. Other inconsistencies-
The article says the event where the rape took place was a "date function". What the fuck is a date function? To my knowledge, there are really two kinds of events; a cocktail, which is brothers and their respective dates, and a party, which is brothers and whoever the fuck else decides to show up. So Jackie was Drew's date, but where were the other guys' dates for the multiple hours they were raping Jackie? The ultimate lame thing to do is to not get a date to a cocktail. If we are still going to assume these guys were pledges, they would have had dates. If we are going to keep assuming PKP are all serial rapists, an upperclassmen brother would not be sacrificing HIS date to get raped by pledges, it would be a pledge's date, because that's just how pledging works. I HOPE YOU CAN SEE THAT THIS IS GETTING MORE ABSURD THE FURTHER IT GOES. Additionally, in what world is gang raping a girl "cool" or "manly"? Furthermore, how is watching your buddy commit rape a bond building activity? Do fraternities tend to objectify women? On the whole, absolutely. Are pledges who have sex with lots of attractive women going to gain more respect from brothers? Unfortunately, yeah, probably. But no one is ever going to think rape is cool except 12 year old Portuguese kids on Xbox Live that beat my ass at FIFA.
I won't even go into asking how Jackie managed to identify everyone in the room despite it being pitch black. Or how she got tackled and went through a plate glass table and didn't have serious lacerations needing stitches.

Furthermore, the whole "gang rape at a fraternity" is an urban myth in the vein of pledges fucking goats during hell week. There is always a rumor that fraternities spike their punch with drugs. That type of shit doesn't happen at UNC or UVA in the 21st century for a number of reasons. First off, if you are the type of person who thinks rape is cool and uses drugs to incapacitate your victims, go kill yourself. Since you won't listen to me there, maybe you'll listen when I will tell you how you're fucking up by using a chainsaw to trim the flowers. Alcohol is plenty sufficient to incapacitate any 100-pound 18 year old girl whose life you feel like ruining. People don't understand that alcohol is a central nervous system depressant. Women metabolize alcohol faster than men, and many times the effects are more profound. If you're drugging a girl, you're more likely to end up adding "defiling a corpse" to your list of charges (which include rape and murder) instead of just hoping they won't remember. In combination with the fact that college is where kids start drinking so they have no tolerance, drugs aren't necessary. Secondly, WHY THE FUCK WOULD I WASTE MY DRUGS ON YOU? Do you have any idea how many Xanax bars would be required in a 50-gallon trash can full of punch to have any sort of effect? You'd have to rob a fucking pharmacy. And if you did rob a pharmacy, why the fuck are you spiking punch? Just take that shit and wake up in 2016 with no idea how you got there.

One time my sophomore year, we had this crazy party for which I made the punch. A bunch of people got stupidly, dangerously drunk. Therefore the punch must have been drugged. I have a confession: the punch was drugged. In the words of the preamble of Narcotics Anonymous, "alcohol is a drug". The punch was only drugged in the sense that I put SIX FUCKING HANDLES OF EVERCLEAR in it, and only God knows how many other handles of Aristocrat vodka as filler. I have to admit it was really fucking stupid. But I was only thinking of myself, because like the good alcoholic that I am, I was aiming to black out after like 3 cups... with little regard to the welfare of everyone else. Pretty sure I achieved that goal.

So yes, dumb shit occurs. But nothing like a lot of people suggest. I would like to say that yes, there are places where fraternities will spike their punch. That is the main difference between Greek systems there and at UVA and UNC. Maybe its some sort of notion of being a "Southern gentleman", or maybe we just aren't creeps.

3. The other characters are less believable than actors in a car insurance commercial
Two of the rapists had nicknames of "Blanket" and "Armpit". Nicknames like that exist solely in the realm of straight-to-DVD American Pie spin-offs, not reality. Fraternity nicknames are (at least 95% of the time) some bastardization of the person's actual name, preferably a bastardization that makes sense for the person. My nickname was Xanax Bar/Xanzibar/Xanny Bar/Zombie Xan. Why? Because my name is Xan and my modus operandi was blacking out on Xanax and smoking cocaine freebase in my cubby while watching The OC for days at a time. Find me a name that is similar to Armpit or Blanket and also supposedly describes kids that would get bids to an "upper tier" fraternity and I will suspend my disbelief. Also, WHAT HUMAN IN AMERICA IN THE TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY WOULD SUGGEST NOT REPORTING A RAPE BECAUSE IT MIGHT HURT THEIR SOCIAL STANDING??? Furthermore, WHAT HUMAN IN ANY CENTURY EVER WOULD SUGGEST THAT JACKIE SHOULD'VE "HAD FUN WITH IT"????? Or that her rapist would say something like "I had fun the other night" when he sees her. ARE YOU FUCKING KIDDING ME? THIS IS MORE RIDICULOUS THAN ANY EPISODE OF SVU IN THE PAST 5 YEARS. I studied sociopathy/antisocial personality disorder in school. I can tell you that Patrick Bateman is 100% fiction. Violent sociopaths (the type that would orchestrate a gang rape and then feel no empathy for the victim after the fact) are almost never high functioning individuals. They have no social skills, no care for their physical appearance, usually have extensive criminal records spanning back to childhood, and most likely never finished high school. They are the type of people whom you meet in passing and they make the hairs on your neck stand up; humans are extremely well adapted to unconsciously recognizing subtle cues such as an emotionless stare or flat affect as a potential threat, which triggers a physiological response. Even the sort of sociopaths that become materially successful in their careers are easily recognized as being rather inauthentic in conversation, though usually the feeling is something along the lines of "something just seemed off". All of that is to say that a violent sociopath is extremely unlikely to attend UVA and receive a bid from an "upper tier" fraternity. A real-life example of a violent sociopath is UVA student Hannah Graham's accused killer Jesse L. Matthew Jr. He wasn't a UVA student. But he was a serial offender, possibly even having killed before. But he's a big black guy, wasn't a student/fraternity member, and doesn't exactly fit the "perfect" narrative. Granted, his abduction/alleged murder of Graham is not typical of most campus assaults. But he is an individual capable of orchestrating a gang rape and being able to sleep at night. It takes a certain kind of monster to be able to hurt others without at least feeling a little pain yourself.

I stand behind the statement in bold above.



So this has been long and rambling, and I might update it later, but this has been bothering me. Do I think Jackie is lying? Not exactly, because I don't really think "Jackie" exists. At best, she is a composite character. At worst, a complete fabrication to put a "name" to what accounts to an urban myth. I intend to criticize both the writer and the editors at Rolling Stone for not adhering to journalistic standards, but producing a piece that while it may be factual, is easily discredited as sensationalist for a variety of reasons. The part of the piece on UVA's "response" (or lack-thereof) to the rape is excellent because it is fact checked, corroborated, and backed up by research. Everything else? Not so much. The author chose an incident which was incredibly compelling but embarrassingly unverifiable. I'm sure there were plenty other survivors who could have shared their stories, but their stories were probably deemed "too boring". No survivor's story is ever "boring", and it should never be considered as an expository narrative towards an investigative piece in order to sell issues or "go viral". I think this is a fucking insult to all survivors of sexual violence that Rolling Stone published this story.


****k bring the hate****

Tuesday, November 25, 2014

Recent events demand my return

Well BreadNation, it looks like we have the clusterfuck to end all clusterfucks on our hands. Like what Kim Kardashian's ass is to asses (and what the woman herself is to completely useless human beings), this is the "überclosterfuchen". I don't speak German, but I highly respect the language's capacity for unnecessarily long but uniquely descriptive words that don't exist in English.

So let's begin.


Ferguson, Missouri (and the documents that virtually none of you will actually take the time to read before posting your opinions on social media)

Last night, a grand jury chose not to bring an indictment against Officer Darren Wilson for killing Michael Brown. The decision is problematic for a number of reasons. However, before we go into this, let's just get this out of the way because it was way too cool for me not to include somehow.
Following images courtesy of this awesome site. I fully encourage everyone to check it out, it is one of the more interesting things I've found on the internet recently.

First off, let's look at the demographics (specifically a visual distribution of demographic data) of St. Louis compared to two other cities of a comparable population and geographic location (i.e. not California). These images are pretty self explanatory, so I'm going to assume that my readers aren't retarded and therefore know how to read/interpret stuff like this. Really I just don't want to type any more than is necessary.
St. Louis, Missouri

Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Lexington, Kentucky
So this might be a completely subjective judgment, but doesn't St. Louis seem to be far more racially segregated than both Pittsburgh and Lexington? I mean in a perfect post-racial bleeding heart wonderland, all our cities would be a nice "fecal matter brown" (coining that one too). Seeing as this is reality, that won't happen. Except it's 2014, and I would expect it to be a little more diverse than it appears.

BUT WAIT... THERE'S MORE (I hope you just heard the voice of Billy Mays in your head)


Approximate location of Ferguson, Missouri circled in red

Approximate border of St. Louis County, Missouri
A lot has been made about the fact that 9/12 members of the grand jury were white. St. Louis County prosecutor Bob McCulloch said that a judge selected the jury to be a representative cross-section of the county. It is hard to tell if 3/4 is a sound proportion; geographically, white people tend to occupy most of the land (maybe roughly 3/4 of the county if you look at it). However, like most cities, whites tend to live in suburbs with a much lower population density than overwhelmingly black urban centers. Courtesy of Wikipedia, St. Louis County is 70.3% White, 23.3% Black. Do with that what you will, because I don't think the makeup of the jury is the problem. 

Here are some assorted observations:
1. Bob McCulloch had no good reason except his own narcissism and personal love of bending over to the police department to wait until after 8 PM local time (9 ET) to announce the decision, especially since the decision wasn't exactly what the hundreds of protestors amassed in the streets wanted to hear. Yes, people were going to flip their shit. Possibly the most disturbing result was at least one white person in power was watching it unfold on TV, stroking their King Charles Spaniel, muttering "yes.... yess.... let the animals tear themselves apart..."

2. It has often been said that "grand juries almost never fail to indict". Yeah, I guess that is true... but not for police officers facing indictments. Police do the dirty work of gathering/analyzing evidence, arresting suspects, etc. Ultimately however, the work that police do on any given case is virtually worthless if the prosecutor cannot produce a conviction using the police's work. In the world of lawyer circle-jerking (especially among prosecutors), having a high conviction rate is your only goal. You're going to have great job security, unlimited upward mobility, and many job offers should you decide to go work for a private firm. As a result, many prosecutors don't want to take anything to trial that they can't win. McCullough wasn't seeking an indictment against Wilson for these two reasons; it would ruin his working relationship with the police department, and it wouldn't produce a conviction.

3. Had an indictment been brought against Officer Wilson, it would have ended in acquittal. Simple as that. People seem to think that if charges were brought, it would mean justice. Fuck no. The majority of witnesses who gave an account along the lines of "Wilson shot Brown as he was running away/surrendering with his hands raised" WERE NOT EVEN FUCKING THERE. At most they heard the gunshots or saw the aftermath. That is the ultimate facepalm in all of this. A bunch of people reporting they witnessed the event just to jump on the bandwagon essentially assured Officer Wilson his freedom. If they can't even keep their stories straight to multiple interviewers, imagine what would happen to these witnesses getting cross-examined on the stand. Never mind the fact that the results of all 3 autopsies essentially refuted the popular narrative.

4. I don't think Officer Wilson is some racist monster. Reading his testimony to the grand jury, it's pretty clear this is just some average guy with average intelligence who probably cares very little about politics or social issues. So basically he was just like any other cop in America. However, deadly force was completely unnecessary; hence why he had Mace and a baton. His testimony makes it very clear he was in a panic during the event. This is where it comes down to training. When adrenaline kicks in and you don't have time to think, you do what you're trained to do. His account of how he reacted with his gun perfectly illustrates this; he pulled the trigger multiple times, and the gun didn't fire. Rather than taking another approach (mace/baton), he still kept pulling the trigger. Eventually when Brown started running away, he had time to "rack it" (cycle a round into the chamber) then resume firing. Lethal force should be a last resort. Officer Wilson's actions suggest his training taught him otherwise.

5. How come the Ferguson police department has smoke grenades, tear gas canisters, flashbangs, assault rifles, armored vehicles, and heavy tactical gear, but doesn't have tasers as standard issue for patrol officers? This further supports my suggestion that their priorities are extremely out of order. If Officer Wilson had a taser and had been trained to use that as the first option if force were necessary, Michael Brown would still be alive.

6. Justice wasn't going to be achieved from inside a very broken system, as I hope I have illustrated. An indictment would have ended in an acquittal, and nothing would have changed. Darren Wilson is just the tip of the iceberg for a much larger problem in our society. I sincerely hope the ongoing federal DOJ probe into the Ferguson police department forces some changes to take place.

7. When white people riot, cops just stand by idly. When people of color riot, they get beaten and gassed. This is an unfortunate fact in 2014. While not quite a riot, when UNC won the National Championship in 2009, I drunkenly carried a jerry can of gasoline out to Franklin Street and started a fire. I remember a few cops just laughing at me as I ran by. Results would be very different if it wasn't a bunch of (mostly) white college kids storming the street.

8. If you're one of the people who thinks we live in some post-racial utopia and that black Americans have the exact same opportunities and social mobility of white Americans, seriously, go fuck yourself. Or go check out that map thing I posted up there and travel to wherever the greenish-yellow area is in your city. Tell some of the people there what you're so willing to vomit all over social media. Please, deliver the LOLs for the rest of us.

In conclusion: bringing an indictment against Officer Wilson would have ended in acquittal. The burden of proof for the indictment is probable cause, which the evidence did not support. It would have been a complete farce to pretend it did, because reasonable doubt (burden of proof for conviction) is easily established. 
The problem is that our current system is too protective of law enforcement officials. They are meant to protect and serve citizens, yet often they are allowed to abuse their authority with no repercussions. Prosecutors aren't willing to shit on their conviction rate and taint their cozy relationship with police. If police aren't accountable to citizens, how can they be expected to enforce the law fairly?

Done for now. More to come later probably.


Edit: St. Louis County Prosecutor is Bob McCulloch. I can't read.

Sunday, July 14, 2013

The Ballad of Trayvon and George


Forget the "ghetto trash trainwreck" star witness for the prosecution, the Skype calls (or lack thereof), or any of the more sensational facts about this case. Better yet, go ahead and completely take race out of the equation, because that seems to be the only thing anyone wants to talk about.

Trayvon Martin was not killed for being black. As much as the news media wants to present the case as the inevitable tragedy of the deeply engrained racial inequalities and prejudices still present in the American South, this case isn't about race.

The prosecution has chosen to say Martin was a victim of the ubiquitous (yet rarely acknowledged) "dangerous black male" stereotype, and that Zimmerman profiled him based on that criteria.
Pointing the finger at Zimmerman's supposed racial prejudice (for which there is virtually no evidence) is why he will go to sleep a free man tonight.

The real problem here is that Trayvon Martin's death was ENTIRELY preventable. We are talking about preventable death on the scale of cigarette smoking, wearing a seatbelt, and fat people.
George Zimmerman did not listen to the dispatcher. Instead, he decided to "play hero" through vigilante justice rather than allow law enforcement to do their job. It is well documented that Zimmerman had an almost child-like obsession with becoming a police officer. Had he followed the dispatcher's instructions to wait for police to arrive, absolutely NONE of this would have happened. In his own words, "these fucking punks always get away", and that is exactly the mentality he carried in approaching Trayvon. As he should have, Trayvon responded indignantly. Being a young black male in this country can be an unpleasant experience, and the prejudice of the "dangerous black male" has been repeatedly confirmed in psychological research.

The problem is that a fist fight ended with a gun shot. The most that Zimmerman should have done is possibly hold Trayvon at gunpoint until police arrived. But he wanted to be the hero.

Am I saying Zimmerman is innocent? He is without a doubt NOT guilty of murder. But the many lesser charges (negligent homicide, manslaughter, etc) for which he could have been found guilty were BARELY explored by the prosecution.

I could go on, and maybe I will later. But consider this: Zimmerman was arrested and charged after the intense public outcry and 24/7 coverage by the news media. Racial conflict creates higher ratings. The death of Trayvon Martin was not because of racial tension. It was the result of one man deciding to take his interpretation of the law into his own hands. And according to the verdict, that vigilantism is perfectly acceptable in the state of Florida.